Honestly, not recommended… most of wins are either on paper or not on livestreams. Very disappointing experience. Prob one of the worst ICT traders.

One of the worst discord,

I have been following his live trading sessions for approximately three months now, and unfortunately my experience has been very disappointing. Most of the live sessions follow a similar pattern: he takes losses during the livestream and then says he is done for the day — or sometimes he only does paper trading and ends the stream early. However, later in the evening, profits are suddenly posted on YouTube or Instagram. These winning trades are taken off-stream and are not shown during the live sessions. Additionally, he sometimes trades on his phone during the livestream. Those trades are not shown or explained. If they turn out to be profitable, they are later posted on Instagram and shared in Discord. This creates a serious transparency issue. There is no clear, verifiable proof of profitability during the live streams themselves. The impression of consistent profits is created mainly through social media posts, not through live, documented execution. Regarding trading competence, I was also not impressed. There is very limited market analysis or structured commentary during the sessions. There have been streams where more time was spent talking about pets and personal matters than actually analyzing the market. Personally, that is not what I paid for. I paid for this subscription expecting transparency, professionalism, and verifiable live trading performance, and that is not what was delivered. For that reason, I cannot recommend this subscription. There are significantly better traders on YouTube who stream daily for free and provide more transparency and value than this paid service.

good work i can recommend

Great group and well worth the money.

Being in the VIP for two months and saw him trading live only twice. First time he took a loss and after the stream he posted a gain saying that he was able to get back. Second time he did not trade at all and posted some gains on the afternoon. He looks like a good guy and very respectful. But if you are looking for “livestream trading”, I’m not sure this channel is for you. I’m giving this channel another month to see how it goes and I will definitely post it here. Again, I am not saying that he lies, I’m just explaining what you will find in the channel. Hope this helps.

No response to my support tickets. Paid full lifetime got no access in discord just all closed up.

Great & organized

Chermane’s discord is amazing. Structured, digestible content for beginners to learn as well as advanced traders to sharpen their skills. Looking forward to his taking it up a level in 2026!

They consistently ignore refund requests and never even reply.

I've been trading for almost 4 years and haven't been consistent. Chermane helped me understand key ICT concepts and thanks to him I got funded and have requested payouts.

Great buy and for me it’s 5 stars you just need to put the work in and watch the content don’t buy this if you want to copy trade and get rich quick not going to be for you. But you definitely learn something in here for sure

He claims to be disciplined. He will take 1-2 losing trades on stream and claim to be “done for the day” then once off stream he’ll post inside his discord he took a “winning trade”. Not a good example at all. If your going to say your done trading be done.

Misleading when purchasing the monthly payment. Paper trades most of the time, did not answer any of my trading question on webinar or live streams.

Chermane helped me level up and get multiple payouts. If you are serious about trading, he's your guy. Nothing but respect and I will be back if my discipline starts to lack. The community helping each other and sharing ideas is an added benefit.

Chermane can trade but if you're looking to see a trader trade LIVE and learn the analysis LIVE this probably isnt the discord for you. youll probably only see him execute LIVE 1-3 times a month. Otherwise you're just learning off his trades he posts that are NOT live. Will you learn this way through his content if you stick to it? Yes possibly, but its doesn't justify the price point of $75/m its worth $40-$50 at best. With the lack of a live service you are better off learning through YouTube for free.

He changed his trading to only tuesdays and Thursday. It’s not even live everyday. How can someone new to this learn without knowing anything

Muy buena comunidad que tengas muchos éxitos Chername

Got banned for being too Gen Z and annoying but its all good Chermane is a good guy

Not as described.

I joined the discord towards the late end of June. Since joining, I've made sure to utilize all of the educational tools provided by Chermane (i.e. his ICT mentorship notes, daily livestreams, weekly webinars, and access to ask questions of him and other discord members). The community is unmatched. I'm not in my 20s and was a bit worried joining this discord because I thought it would be full of younger traders and not as serious. However, everyone I interacted with in the chat were respectful, knowledgeable, and FOCUSED on getting results. This is not a discord for anyone looking for handouts. You are paying to learn how to fish on your own. There were numerous times where many of us in the chat were able to identify and execute the same profitable trades based upon what we have learned and observed from Chermane. Do the work, show up and actively participate in the daily livestreams, and trade one of the 3+ models Chermane has gone over numerous times and you will find your way! In hindsight, I wish I had signed up for the lifetime membership but I definitely don't regret the investment! I'm leaving the group after securing 3 funded accounts and now comfortably trading my personal capital!

Do not join, especially if you're considering a "lifetime" membership. I paid for lifetime access and was banned from the Discord in under a year—not for breaking rules, but for agreeing (with a thumbs-up emoji) when others called out his lack of transparency. Yes, you might learn a thing or two, but the mentorship is full of red flags: He hides his actual entries and exits, giving vague commentary after the fact. Criticism is not allowed—members get banned for asking fair questions or raising concerns. The Discord community gaslights anyone who dares to speak up. Refunds are blocked, and what’s delivered is not what was promised or advertised. What’s most disappointing is the hypocrisy: someone who constantly references Christianity while silencing members and withholding refunds is not someone I can trust. If you’re serious about trading, don’t waste your money here. You’ll end up disappointed, like I did—and fighting for your money back.

I was able to cover the cost of the lifetime membership in less than a week. Here's how: I LISTENED to how he ANALYZED price action and took note of what behaviors in price gave him CONFIDENCE or CAUTION. I took my time and watched his free content on youtube as well as the webinars in discord. Then I went into my charts to find examples of what he was highlighting. This man is calm and very disciplined for a reason. He's a student who's put time in on the charts. His risk parameters are tight and once he hits his profit he knows how to stop trading when both green and red. Many traders can not do that. If you want/need someone to tell you when to buy or sell and you aren't willing to do the work to have confidence in making that decision yourself, don't join. If you want access to educational content (Annotations, Webinars, Live taperead, execution videos, trading models, etc) tap in, it's for you. Also.. NY AM ATM Model is immaculate....truly...

He's a good trader who explains logic, bias and narrative pretty well in my opinion. He has good profitability on his accounts and transparent about wins and losses. Well worth the money, a pretty good mentor to improve the trading skills.

After watching Chermane’s YouTube videos and seeing how effortlessly he explains trading, I didn’t think twice before getting the lifetime subscription to his Discord. A few months in, and the impact on my trading journey has been nothing but positive. Chermane is not just a great mentor—he’s someone who makes complex concepts easy to understand. I truly appreciate the clarity and simplicity of his trading style.

For this price, it’s absolutely TOP value. There’s a daily livestream with Cherman where you can see exactly which trades he takes. He explains every single thing he sees and tells you why he made each decision. The community is fantastic — if you don’t understand something, people on Discord will answer you within 5 minutes. Cherman gives you homework, market reviews, and there’s a weekly webinar. For me, this is top-notch.

This is a great community. Respectful traders in the chat. Chermane is very responsible and keeps a great schedule. Genuinely wants to help people trade without giving them signals. You can trade along, but the point is to learn to do it with rules and not by following or being sent a signal. Videos links to YouTube are typically available for review over the weekend and then deleted, so don't expect lots of trading history, but in the Discord, he does provide reviews of the significant rules followed for each trade. Pleasure to tune into his live streams since he keeps them drama free and focused just on trading.

If you're truly willing to put in the time and study his webinars, as well as utilize all his resources, you won't be disappointed 100%. 7 days into studying old webinars from 2024, and I've passed 2 eval accounts so far. From experience, this is one of the more reliable trading groups that i've been in and you'll 100% get what you paid for. 100% recommended.

I’ve been in his discord for over a year… great trader but is not transparent AT ALL.. majority of all his wins you see on social media are NOT live traded… he’ll lose on a stream and then revert his next streams back to “tape reading” streams so he doesn’t have to show any entries… he’s a great trader and I’ve learned a lot but all I did was call out his hidden/sneaky entries and then he blocked me and took me out the discord… sucks to even be writing this review TBH… it was fun while it lasted but it is NOT what he advertises it to be… stay humble

After hopping from one paid mentorship to another, I’ve never felt this confident—until now. The way Chermane explains things just clicks and clears up all my confusion. The value he brings to the Discord community is incredible, and honestly, his pricing is a total steal compared to other mentorship programs out there. He’s still seriously underrated. I’ve learned so much, and now I finally feel ready to take on the world. If you want to learn how to trade independently—not just blindly copy trades—Chermane is the right place for you.

I think chermane is a really great trader but not for me personally i dont think hes a scammer like many of these reviews say but hes def not the best teacher but trading he can for sure

Very disappointed signing up. Firstly I’m not a trade copier but he kept emphasis to everyone that he’s not a signal platform. Then when he takes trade on his Apex he doesn’t share nor explain about what is happening, only sharing about everything else other than the PA that is happening. Only after the trade plays out then he started bragging about his trade “I took it here blah blah”. Mentioned live trading, but more like just explaining ICT concepts about wicks, dealing ranges, what we should expect , but never about the current PA UNTIL it plays out then he will start bragging and taking all the screenshots. Not only that, he’s done with his live acc for the month and started going on paper, and his paper trades doesn’t make sense. I’ve seen way better streamer that streams for free and explains in depth and the trades they take.

dont buy this, run away. ran far far far far away. no such thing as a live trading with him like he advertises on his socials. your gonna keep losing money lol. RUN AWAY RUN AWAY. i would give this a -10 stars if i could lol

He’s a closed n fixated mind. Your play is when price knocks sellside u look for buy and vice versa. Problem is when price doesn’t reverse you don’t know the signature. And when you decide to trade off camera and you win(PM, where he doesn’t go live), problem is you don’t wanna do anything in the AM you kinda half ass it and call it a day when u don’t find set ups in 30 minutes, that’s just not cool.

Chermane is a very good trader. But his man focus is not you or his community, It’s to pay his bills. I joined and been here for two months and he’s only traded winning trades with us maybe 5 times the rest are losses or he trades privately off camera. Again that’s fine but don’t advertise as if you’re here to help all of us and learn from you.

Chermaine was making red trades back to back and i criticized him on his youtube channel. no insults nothing. told him he has problem reading the bias. he replied me to leave the discord , erased my comment and banned me. Believe me he is not capable of teaching ICT concepts because he even cant analyze where draw of liquidity is

Chermaine is Awesome. His psychology is so on point that people in the discord are mad because he is not trading more. He is practicing discipline and that is the main thing with trading. I can mark up the chart and find all the "right" levels but I am undiscipled and that is why I am in the discord. My future is on the other side of my discipline, I recognize that and Chermaine displays that well in his trading/ livestreams. If you want signals and everything spoon fed, go somewhere else.

If you’re truly serious about learning ICT concepts 📚 and want to grow with real knowledge 🧠 — this is THE place. You’re not just joining any server — you're learning from the best ICT mentor out there 🔥. The Premium Discord 💎 is absolutely worth it if your goal is to understand the strategy and become independent. But if you're just looking to copy signals to make fast money, this is the wrong place for you. Charemen is an amazing mentor 🙌 — incredibly dedicated, super skilled, and also a man of God ✝️. That makes the experience even more powerful. Highly recommend to anyone who truly wants to learn and evolve 📈

If you genuinely want to get better at trading this is where you need to be. This discord is for traders by an actual trader. You have to be willing to put in the work but Chermane makes it easier by giving you insight on what you should be paying attention to but does not spoon feed it

I just want to say how grateful I am to have found Chermane’s trading Discord. He really has a gift for teaching ICT concepts in a way that just clicks. In such a short time, I’ve learned so much—from holding my trades with confidence to knowing what to actually look for while in the market. What I love most is that this isn’t a signal group. Chermane actually teaches you how to become independent by giving out homework, doing detailed market reviews, and hosting weekly classes. He’s super responsive and genuinely wants to see you win. I’ve grown a lot more confident thanks to him.

If you're serious about mastering Inner Circle Trader (ICT) concepts with genuine discipline, I HIGHLY Chermane's discord server. What truly sets this discord apart is the commitment to live trading sessions and live tape reading, offering a real-time environment to see ICT strategies in action. This practical exposure, combined with a supportive community of like-minded traders, fosters significant growth in reading price action and developing sound risk management. For those dedicated to truly understanding and executing ICT with precision, Chermane's discord is a valuable resource.

The most authentic trader streaming. Don't join if you want to be spoon fed cus this is not that. If you truly want to LEARN how to be a good trader, one who can understand price action and proper risk management, then this is the place to be.

Chermaine is the real deal l! I came into his discord already understanding ICT concepts but wanted to see someone with similar trade ideas. His discord is great whether or not you are a beginner or advanced trader. Definitely not a furu and is legit. I think anyone who is open to live trading and actually seeing their positions is the real deal.

I joined for one reason only - to see how Chermane thinks when he is on the charts. I already knew how to trade but my consistency was very very poor. For me it was all about learning to trust myself because he often mentioned that he always felt like he was in control of his emotions and his risk because of which he was able to regulate his emotions well. This little piece was what I was missing. If you want to copy trades, find another place to do so because here, it is all about mindset which is unarguably the most important thing in trading. Thanks my dude!

Chermane has really elevated my trading in only a week of me joining this discord, I often can get overwhelmed with the amount of knowledge I have learnt from ICT and struggle to apply everything into my trading. This is where Chermane came in, the simplicity of his model instantly clicked with my and I’ve never looked back. My trading has been the best it ever has been and I would highly recommend to anyone reading this that this discord is the best investment you will make. From the education aspect to the great community he has build really makes it a great environment to study and learn from every day.

What I like the most with Chermane's discord is the level of structure and discipline with every aspect of services he offers. From the high quality lecture videos, concise weekly analysis, in-depth webinars, to the live trading streams where he provides a wealth of knowledge in the moment. Everything about it is so orderly and intentional - it's very pleasing. Highly recommend the channel along with the great community that comes with it

I signed up for the sole reason of following Chermagne live trading sessions. He would literally enter almost every fair value gap he sees on 1 minute chart, go 0/4 trades live and state how he’s happy with his risk management. Stay away, you’re better off without.

One of the best learning station one could so many norms i had but got away by watching videos of my mentor Chermane still learning .I will recommend this before you even buy a funded account.

Weekly webinars, daily livestreams, serious community, and weekly outlooks, daily reviews, I mean, if you can't find gems and knowledge through all of this, you're looking for handouts and not trying.

I've been following Chermane's live streams, and while he's good at chart drawing, his trade execution is consistently poor. He often enters trades after the move has already happened, which is frustrating to watch—this is not how ICT trades. Additionally, there is no real educational content, despite his claim that he covers ICT lectures. Before subscribing to Full Access, I was told these lectures would be included, but after checking the Discord, I found that none of them were actually covered. I initially requested a refund due to this misleading claim, but it was denied. Don't waste your money on this subscription—it was a disappointing experience, and I wouldn't recommend it to anyone looking for serious ICT education. My rating: One star, and even that feels too generous due to the false promises and poor execution.